How to Turn First-Time Guests Into Repeat Customers at Your Restaurant or Bar — Without Running Discounts

If you’re like most restaurant or bar owners, you put a ton of effort into getting new guests through the door. You post on social. You run ads. You train your staff. And when people show up, you deliver a great experience.

But here’s the part most places miss:

What happens after that guest pays their bill and walks out the door?

For a lot of restaurants, the answer is: nothing. And that’s where revenue is lost.

In today’s saturated market, hope isn’t a retention strategy. If you don’t have a simple, intentional way to bring that guest back, there’s a good chance they’ll never return — even if they loved the experience.

So how do you fix that — without running constant discounts?

Let’s walk through it.

Step 1: Make Return Visits Part of the Guest Experience

One of the easiest, most effective ways to encourage repeat business is to turn the end of the guest experience into a moment of fun.

That’s exactly what we do with our Scratch-Off Game System.

Here’s how it works:

• Guest pays their bill

• Server offers them a QR code or tablet to play a quick game

• They play a branded digital scratch-off and win something like:

  • A free appetizer

  • A $5 discount

  • A drink on their next visit

  • A piece of merch

• They enter their name, email, and phone to redeem the prize

Boom — they’ve just had a great time, they’ve won something, and they now have a reason to return within the next week or two.

Why It Works: Psychology > Promotions

This isn’t about bribing guests to come back with 20% off coupons.

This is about engagement and the law of reciprocity — when you give someone something unexpected, they feel inclined to return the favor.

Guests walk out thinking, “Well, now I have to come back to use this.”

It works the same way it worked for decades in McDonald’s Monopoly. People came back for the thrill of the game, not just the food.

Real Example:

A bar client of ours tested this system over the course of a month. Staff kept it simple — just handed the QR code with the check and said, “Hey, we’re running a fun giveaway. Scan and scratch to win.”

They saw dozens of guests return just to use their prize. Many brought a friend. Some left Google reviews. All of it happened without extra effort from the team.

What You Gain:

• More return visits — not weeks later, but within days

• Contact info from guests you otherwise wouldn’t be able to reach again

• A built-in moment of delight at checkout that guests talk about

• More 5-star reviews (because the prize triggers a follow-up text with a review link)

Final Thought

You don’t need to discount your menu to get people to return.
You just need to give them a reason that’s fun, frictionless, and unforgettable.

If you're ready to stop relying on chance and start turning first-time guests into repeat customers, let’s show you how it works.

📲 Watch the demo

Contact us

Whether you have a request, a query, or want to work with us, use the form below to get in touch with our team.